An Open Letter Regarding The Pseudo-Religious Ideology of Racial Purity: An Episcopal and Theological Exhortation

Bishops Are Not Political Pundits

An Episcopal and Theological Exhortation




Bishops are not political pundits. We are equally the pastors to Republicans, Democrats,

Independents, and others. We would not presume to instruct people how to vote. Immigration

policy is a worry for Americans of various perspectives, and politicians should grapple with the

question. However, bishops are teachers of the faith as well shepherds of the souls of our

parishioners. We speak specifically as such.




Donald Trump, our former President, has recently called immigrants ‘vermin,’ and had said

that they ‘poison the blood of our country.’ A clearer example of racism, in this case with an

eugenic edge, one could not find. When the parallels to Nazi rhetoric were pointed out, Trump

claimed he knew no such thing. But then he repeated the very same statements, when he most

certainly was aware of the parallels.




The idea of racial purity is an idol, something false and harmful to which people bind

themselves. As such it presents a corrupt doctrine of the human person, since it is the human

being per se who is ‘in the image of God’ (Genesis 1:26).




Here we do well to note a modern doctrinal tradition which can help to inform us. The fight

against the racialist German Christians led to the insight that acquiescence amounted to allowing

another leader (Fuehrer) over the Church than Christ (see The Barmen Declaration of 1934). Two

generations later, the Alliance of Reformed Churches in 1982 declared at Ottawa that ‘apartheid

is heresy’, for behind it is a ‘pseudo-religious ideology.’ To be sure these examples involve political

movements of greater duration and articulation than we are at present dealing with. But alluding

to these precedents, as we call out such a trend of thought early, is warranted. In the case of the

former President’s repeated statements, the false teaching implied in his statements is the same.

The ancient serpent moves through such words.




And so, in our capacity as bishops, we adjure our flocks to reject this false teaching. We exhort

political leaders to speak up in its condemnation. We invite fellow Christian leaders to cleave to

the Word of God and to separate themselves explicitly from such a thought. Finally, we express

our hope that our nation can, at this juncture, by God’s grace, follow the ‘better angels of our

nature.’




Signed,




The Rt. Rev. Cathleen Bascom, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Kansas

The Rt. Rev. Larry Benfield, Bishop Resigned of the Episcopal Diocese of Arkansas

The Rt. Rev. Mark Cowell, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Western Kansas

The Rt. Rev. Andy Doyle, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Texas

The Rt. Rev. Jeff Fisher, Bishop Suffragan of the Episcopal Diocese of Texas

The Rt. Rev. Michael Hunn, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of the Rio Grande

The Rt. Rev. Fraser Lawton, Assistant Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Dallas

The Rt. Rev. Scott Mayer, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Northwest Texas

The Rt. Rev. Jacob Owensby, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Western Louisiana

The Rt. Rev. Poulson Reed, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Oklahoma

The Rt. Rev. Kathryn Ryan, Bishop Suffragan of the Episcopal Diocese of Texas

The Rt. Rev. Michael Smith, Assistant Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Dallas

The Rt. Rev. George Sumner, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Dallas